Apr to Nov · Mon to Sat, 11am to 7pm Order ahead: (315) 531-8700
An overhead spread of ribs, cornbread, macaroni salad, cole slaw, BBQ beans, macaroni and cheese, salt potatoes, a pulled pork sandwich and fresh cut fries
Penn Yan, New York · Family owned since 2016

Low and slow. Every single day.

Brisket, ribs and pulled pork smoked until they fall apart, plus giant BBQ chicken quarters. Salads made in small batches, burgers pressed by hand, fries cut fresh.

  • Eat in or take out
  • Family combos
  • Catering
  • Kids meals
A West Lake Plate: macaroni salad and home fries under housemade meat sauce
FLX Finest

Five medals in two years

Judged across the Finger Lakes by FLX Local Media. The plates have taken gold two years running.

Plates

  • Gold 2025
  • Gold 2026

Catering

  • Gold 2025
  • Silver 2026

BBQ & Burger

  • Bronze 2026
Ribs cooking over the coals in the Meadow Creek smoker with smoke rolling out
How we cook

Nothing here is in a hurry

Our barbecue is smoked low and slow, which is the only way to get meat that falls off the bone. The rest of the kitchen works the same way.

  • Salads made in house, in small batches
  • Burgers pressed by hand, never frozen pucks
  • Fries cut fresh, skin on
  • Family owned, family operated, family friendly
Regulars order these

A few of the favorites

The Sampler

Ribs, chicken, and two sliders each of pulled pork and beef brisket. Two sides and cornbread.

$24 dinner combo

"Roger That"

Beef brisket, pulled pork and pulled chicken piled on a DiPaolo roll and topped with BBQ sauce.

$18 lunch combo

The Puckered Pig

Pulled pork sandwich under cheese sauce, BBQ sauce and bacon.

$17.50 lunch combo

Feeding a crowd this summer?

Pulled pork from $19 a head, ribs from $23, with two sides, plates and serving utensils included. Half chicken orders need a week's notice.

Plan the catering